This Week's Herman Trend Alert

Cut the Fat to Lose More Weight

  The Herman Trend Alert

August 8, 2000

Span of Control

143 Days until January 1, 2001

Are things getting out of control in the way we manage today? No, but there are significant changes in management philosophy.

For decades, business students at our universities have carefully studied the science of management, including such issues as span of control. The concept deals with how many people a manager or supervisor can control and still maintain productivity and discipline. (For our younger readers who may not have studied this topic, those words may be somewhat uncomfortable, but for many years the words "management" and "control" have been synonymous.

In some types of work, requiring closer supervision, a span of control of 1:5 may have been appropriate. This ratio means that management scientists believed that one could adequately oversee the work of five other people, no more. If the supervisor had to assume responsibility for six people, for instance, quality and performance would suffer. In other kinds of work, where people could work more independently, a ratio of 1:10 or even more might work.

Recently, we've noted substantial changes in the concept of span of control. While we are still concerned about controlling quality, performance, efficiency, and other aspects of how people work, we are less dictatorial about the process. We've shifted to more monitoring than control at the supervisory level, equipping workers with methods to measure and control their own performance. We've pushed accountability down in many organizations, though some employers still have some work to do. The mode now is more support, than control-some professors now describe the concept as "span of support".

Workers are becoming much more independent. Life values have changed, encouraging people to assume more responsibility and accountability. Work values have changed, as well, encouraging more focus on individual worker performance and less on supervision. Labor shortages, streamlining, and changes in corporate philosophy have reduced the number of managers and supervisors, further supporting a wider "span of support."

As workers become more collaborative and there is less need for direct supervision, especially controlling, watch for the ratios to change even more. Managers will be charged with more support and coordination and less regulation.

Comments from our readers:

Just a thought for you -- as we looked at spans of control recently here at my company the whole notion of matrix management was factoring much more heavily into the mix -- i.e., what if someone has only 5 direct reports but has a virtual team of 15-20 or more? To me, the virtual teams/matrix management issue is one of the most significant organizational design changes, making the old ways of thinking about spans of control obsolete.

© Copyright 1998- by The Herman Group, Inc. -- reproduction for publication is encouraged, with the following attribution: From "The Herman Trend Alert," by Joyce Gioia, Strategic Business Futurist. 336-210-3547 or To sign up, visit The Herman Trend Alert is a trademark of The Herman Group, Inc."

To find the translation for Tikkun Olam for last week's Herman Trend Alert, I went to Google Translate. Not surprisingly, it was not a great translation. Actually Tikkun Olam means "repairing the world". Special thanks to reader Jeff Rothman for this information. JLG

On March 1st, Joyce graduated from Clint Arthur's Celebrity Launchpad. Since then, she has made twenty-one appearances on local television stations, including Fox San Diego and CBS Las Vegas. In a couple of weeks, Joyce will start a new TV Media Tour with her new segment: How Soon Will You Be Replaced By a Robot? (coming soon to a television station near you) You can see most Joyce's appearances on her travel website at You can do it, too! If you sign up for Celebrity Launchpad, you will qualify for a free coaching session from Joyce in your chosen area. Launchpad's are held monthly, but space is limited. For more information, call Joyce at 336.210.3548.

Look no further than A fraction of the cost you will pay for domestic hosting. For more information, email Expect to be surprised and pleased.

Both Joyce Gioia (our author) and her husband have benefited from taking micronized purple rice. Joyce's husband, a cancer survivor, is in better health today than before he was diagnosed with Stage 3B colon cancer. He has seen his Stage 2 KIdney Disease improve significantly---his doctor just dismissed him for six months and his cancer marker (CEA) lab tests show the lowest in his life at 3.8 (5.0 and under is considered normal; labs available upon request). Joyce has personally experienced hair regrowth and the fading of spider veins, along with improved energy and other health benefits. To learn more about this remarkable supplement, call Joyce at 336.210.3548 or email her at

To read this Herman Trend Alert on the web: http://

Herman Trend Alerts are produced by the Herman Group, strategic business futurists, Certified Management Consultants, authors, and professional speakers.

New subscribers are welcome. There is no charge for this public service. The Herman Trend Alert is read by over 30,000 people in 87 countries, including other websites and printed periodicals. Do you enjoy receiving this weekly e-mail update? Contact us about our co-branded Herman Trend Alert service. Click here to sign up for the Herman Trend Alert.

Subscribe or Unsubscribe to weekly Herman Trend Alert
View this week's Herman Trend Alert
Archived Weekly Herman Trend Alerts


[ Home About Products Resources Media ]


7112 Viridian Lane
Austin, TX 78739
Voice: 336-210-3547
Toll Free in US & Canada: 800-227-3566

  © The Herman Group. All rights reserved.

Web site design by WebEditor Design Services, Inc.